Eclectic Collection of Caving Related Ephemera

yrammy

Active member
The British Caving Library has a laarge ring binder full of various caving related ephemera. These include :
Beer Labels
Chocolate Labels
Cigarette Cards
Trade Cards
Tickets
Bank Notes
Match Cards.

We are not going to retain these in the library but do not know what they are worth (if anything) whtehr anyone would bew interessted in obtaining them.

We would be interested in your views on this.
 

Attachments

  • 1000019802.jpg
    1000019802.jpg
    81.8 KB · Views: 158
  • 1000019803.jpg
    1000019803.jpg
    79.4 KB · Views: 150
  • 1000019804.jpg
    1000019804.jpg
    81.6 KB · Views: 150
  • 1000019806.jpg
    1000019806.jpg
    72.5 KB · Views: 152
I think this is absolutely the sort of collection that should be retained by the BCL, for the reason given by ZombieCake.

Further, seemingly arbitrary decisions such as yrammy presents as a fait accompli should not be made until endorsed by discussion with the library's funders (BCA) and the organisation which set up the library (BCRA): has such discussion taken place and been formally endorsed? Perhaps the scope of what the library should collect needs a clearer definition, if indeed there is any such definition at all?

langcliffe makes a good proposal, but it requires full scanning and preferably cataloguing, before any disposal.

Surely, especially if it is only one ringbinder, albeit large, the pragmatic solution is to retain this collection?
 
how about digitising the archive and then donating the physical aspect to:


they might be interested, either that or digitise and then the antiques market and bung the proceeds back into fund?
 
I was not as clear as I wanted to be in my previous post for want of effort (I currently don't have an operational right arm, and haven't yet established a rapprochement between my left hand and the mouse).

I agree with most of the replies above. I think they should be retained, catalogued, and possibly placed on the Online Archive. I can quite imagine somebody researching the history of show caves in the UK, and wanting to see every advert, every leaflet, every postcard etc., and there is nowhere else they can go.

Now that I have (more-or-less) finished with the Hensler material, I would be happy to take on the job. I should have my arm back in a month.
 
I would hope that any collections of cave-related stamps and postcards would also be welcome in the BCL and/or the BCRA Online Archive. The Mendip Cave Registry and Archive has Dave Irwin's catalogue to his postcard collection speleo-philately is by no means an unknown interest
 
A little while ago I was involved in a project for a museum photographing an archive collection of various items that couldn't be scanned, e.g. glass jars, signs, 3D objects, and so on. Photos taken from all angles to capture the detail. Idea was to have a collection of images for online research and archive purposes. The physical items were retained in the collection and could be looked at by appointment. Perhaps not totally groundbreaking, however, very useful for future researchers in a number of disciplines. And yes, we did all get an invite to the exhibition launch evening!
 
If Langcliffe is happy to digitise the collection, that's obviously a good way to go as a first step. That way the collection becomes available to everyone to view. We can then make a firm decision as to whether BCL ought to retain the originals.

Part of our problem at BCL is space - we are victims of our own success! We simply do not have room to store everything we would like to and are having to make decisions about what we should keep as physical items, as opposed to what can be digitised and the originals passed on to people with a special interest. Ideally, given unlimited money to pay for the space and the staff to deal it all, BCL would keep everything. But ...

Answers on a (caving) postcard please.
 
Some items are kept in every club library around the country, so aren't so important, but tend to be the things that everyone wants to look at...
 
Might a useful rule of thumb to apply befor evrn considering disposal be: "If we can't identify another caving body where this material is available, we must not dispose of it"?
mikem's point about 'popular' material would mean that BCL could possibly save space by keeping such things in less accessible storage than open shelves and directing the more casual enquirers elsewhere....
 
All I will say is that it was not an arbitary decision - it followed consultation with the BCRA representative who was instrumental in acquiring the collection in the first place. I entirley agree with the idea of getting the items scanned and on the website - although we are talking about a large number of files and folders , not just the one that was offered in this post. I also entirley agree with 'Perhaps the scope of what the library should collect needs a clearer definition' - something we have been asking for for many years.
 
Note that BCL does keep a record of the enquiries we receive and what people are after, so we have a good idea of the general run of enquiries. I can't recall when we were last asked about some of these more specialist items.
Having scans of these items online would be useful and might attract enquiries if people knew that we had these items at BCL. However, there are around 20 of these files of ephemera, which is a huge job in terms of scanning. Bear in mind that, as yrammy says, this is just the first one which we have publicised to see if anyone was interested.
 
Back
Top