I was brought up caving in steel toe capped leather laceups but decided to switch to gummies (wellies to u poms) when I destroyed a pair of leather boots in ten days.
The best wellies I ever had were a pair of Clydes made by Skellrup in New Zealand: Gum Comando style sole, black PVC uppers, no caps and close fitting. these were of a thicker material than Surtreds, lasted for ages and stuck like glue to rock. At the time they also made a boot called the Trent which looked the same except that the sole was similar to that on the Surtred. Sadly Kiwi farmers don't like close fitting boots so they were replaced by the RD2000. These are still popular back in NZ but they flop around a bit and it doesn't take long before you have to empty the Southern Alps out of your boots. The other boot popular in NZ is the white Abattoir boot made by Bata. These PVC wellies are built like brick shit houses but only stick to nice clean rock so are very popular for river caving (and also because all they are supplied free to all the Black Water Rafting type cave guides in NZ and therefore thereare always lots of freebees lying around)
So now I cave in Surtreds (since 1996) close fitting to keep the crap out and to support the ankle, solid, so long lasting and they have a good grippy sole but sadly my non steel caped pair have split and there is no where local I can replace them. However, saying that I really need a bigger size and they never came bigger than a 12 (I always caved in woollen socks because wet socks didn't fit) so does anyone know of a good quality close fitting good soled gripping welly in a size 13? without steel caps?