Badlad said:
This is very interesting - and highlights one of the issues that was at the heart of the CNCC problems of last year. Namely that club reps were not reflecting the views of the club members.
For example; there was a proposal put to the CNCC committee by one of the influential officers last September which was voted through unanimously. It was somewhat controversial (as is the Drws Cefn issue) and had to go to a further vote due to a constitutional amendment. After some publicity of the issue, many of the club reps were brought to task. Individual club members asked questions and clubs had to seriously consider the issue they were voting for. In the end the vote was turned around 100%, with the same proposal being rejected unanimously at the AGM.
If all the facts of the Drws Cefn issue were known I cannot believe that the majority of cavers from that region wish to see this entrance concreted in or closed in any other way. I hope that UBSS members will give a greater consideration to what their club is doing to their name.
Me too, its horrifying to think that the views of the members may not have been properly represented, not just in the UBSS but any club. ( although i can understand the difficulty in aquiring consensus especially in clubs the size of say the wessex.)
There seems to be a strong rumbling that this selective " democracy" that exists in UK caving politics is being exposed for the charade it is.
My favorite quote was from jasonbirder on a different thread
People who ENJOY verbose and procedure driven meetings feel that decisions are best taken BY those who enjoy procedure driven and verbose meetings...as their input is obviously more valid and important than those who don't enjoy them/are intimidated by the atmosphere/haven't the time or money to participate...
It gave me an understanding how people can drive forward their own agendas, by barracking, intimidation and droning on until most non politicians get fed up and go away.
I will admit at this point to not wanting to voice my opinion on this subject/thread because of the relentless brow bashing opinions and heckling that the regular few always descend to.
As for the Derbyshire key thing, Brilliant, access for all at the consent of all. How unfashionably fair and straight forward.
The locks on mendip are often a bit of a headache to maintain, often resulting in cancelled trips or rescues when people get locked in caves.