• CSCC Newsletter - May 2024

    Available now. Includes details of upcoming CSCC Annual General Meeting 10th May 2024

    Click here for more info

BMC changes its name to Climb Britain

NewStuff

New member
Carbide1 said:
Another respected organisation racing to the bottom. :mad:

You're a stuffy old lot in here. It's a *name change*. It may not have the pomp and circumstance perceived by some of you as appropriate for the body, but you are not where the market is heading. It's younger people, significantly younger, that will ensure the body continues to survive, and they need to be relevant to even think about retaining members and push the interests of it's members.

Just as the BCA is doing now, despite the odd scream of old people that refuse to play nicely.
 

Over the Hill

New member
BMC lost its way some time ago and still the best value all around for International "CLIMB" trips is to join the OEAV or as known in UK as the Austrian Alpine Club. Cheaper and some good insurance thrown in (personal choice to check if it covers all you want it too as it has limits but caving is included) . Also gets me discounts staying in huts where a BMC card does not.
 

Simon Wilson

New member
NewStuff said:
Carbide1 said:
Another respected organisation racing to the bottom. :mad:

You're a stuffy old lot in here. It's a *name change*. It may not have the pomp and circumstance perceived by some of you as appropriate for the body, but you are not where the market is heading. It's younger people, significantly younger, that will ensure the body continues to survive, and they need to be relevant to even think about retaining members and push the interests of it's members.

Just as the BCA is doing now, despite the odd scream of old people that refuse to play nicely.

That's what I was thinking too but I didn't dare say so. Unfortunately a lot of effort seems to have had to be wasted by Climb Britain in having to explain the change.
 

andrewmcleod

Well-known member
Over the Hill said:
BMC lost its way some time ago and still the best value all around for International "CLIMB" trips is to join the OEAV or as known in UK as the Austrian Alpine Club. Cheaper and some good insurance thrown in (personal choice to check if it covers all you want it too as it has limits but caving is included) . Also gets me discounts staying in huts where a BMC card does not.

Be careful with the limits on AAC insurance though - you may just about be OK in Europe but the cover is definitely not enough for some places. BMC insurance is provided by a (recently changed) broker and is expensive but comprehensive with much higher limits.
 

Over the Hill

New member
Yes agreed OEAV has "Insurance Limits" as does every Insurance Policy including the BMC but I thought I had made that point ?
It's up to the individual to read the small print as Insurance Companies exist for one purpose only, you won't need 2 guesses for that.
 

andrewmcleod

Well-known member
Over the Hill said:
Yes agreed OEAV has "Insurance Limits" as does every Insurance Policy including the BMC but I thought I had made that point ?
It's up to the individual to read the small print as Insurance Companies exist for one purpose only, you won't need 2 guesses for that.

The misunderstanding is probably my fault! I should have said 'cost limits' (e.g. rescue costs limit for AAC is ?25,000, for BMC is ?100,000) or something whereas I think your post was more referring to activity type limits (i.e. caving included).
 

Over the Hill

New member
No issues there Andrew but the biggest factor for me is that the OEAV (AAC UK) throw in the insurance for free with the membership fee and that is not that much in the grand scheme of things. With the BMC (as was) its was a always add on.

That said I have carried both memberships in the past having worked out that a fall off a big mountain in Alaska a few year ago would have been outside the scope of the AAC cover. And for those that want a real bargain head South to New Zealand and fall off big style with no insurance as its like the UK currently with no charges for a heli rescue (proved that one in January, ouch).
 

NewStuff

New member
Simon Wilson said:
That's what I was thinking too but I didn't dare say so. Unfortunately a lot of effort seems to have had to be wasted by Climb Britain in having to explain the change.

I'm not exactly shy about calling things as I see them. I'm already on a number of "blacklists" so I thought we would see how many more we can add, it's great fun!
 

bograt

Active member
Does anyone else think this may be as a result of 'climbing' (Indoor bouldering) becoming a potentially competitive Olympic Sport ????

Also, I remember the debacle of the BT man drinking a yard of ale !!-------....

BT_Piper.jpg
 

topcat

Active member
bograt said:
Does anyone else think this may be as a result of 'climbing' (Indoor bouldering) becoming a potentially competitive Olympic Sport ????

Also, I remember the debacle of the BT man drinking a yard of ale !!-------....

Exactly this...................tail wagging the dog again.
 

andrewmcleod

Well-known member
bograt said:
Does anyone else think this may be as a result of 'climbing' (Indoor bouldering) becoming a potentially competitive Olympic Sport ????

It's actually indoor lead climbing (which they confusingly refer to as 'sport climbing' despite that more normally being the same activity outside) but I don't think so because:
a) it was Sport England (grassroots) not UK Sport (elite sport)
b) all this started at least 9 months ago, long before the recent anouncement.
 

Clive G

Member
If caving is going to go along with 'the scene', then in spite of the fact there's a book out there with the same name (by the inventor of Descent), given you want to include caving, potholing and mines exploration, it would have to be something like:

Underground Britain

But - thanks to Richard Bartrop - 20 years ago (in 1996) we discovered Hidden Earth, so we're actually leading rather than behind the times with 'smart names'!
 

NewStuff

New member
Clive G said:
If caving is going to go along with 'the scene', then in spite of the fact there's a book out there with the same name (by the inventor of Descent), given you want to include caving, potholing and mines exploration, it would have to be something like:

Underground Britain

But - thanks to Richard Bartrop - 20 years ago (in 1996) we discovered Hidden Earth, so we're actually leading rather than behind the times with 'smart names'!

I was saying that the BCA has been making inroads into changing it's attitude towards access and members, rather than it's name. Hidden, Earth, Underground Britain, TroglodytesRus, I'm not really bothered.
 

tamarmole

Active member
Clive G said:
If caving is going to go along with 'the scene', then in spite of the fact there's a book out there with the same name (by the inventor of Descent), given you want to include caving, potholing and mines exploration, it would have to be something like:

Underground Britain

But - thanks to Richard Bartrop - 20 years ago (in 1996) we discovered Hidden Earth, so we're actually leading rather than behind the times with 'smart names'!

If we want to be really up to date and down with the yoof how about:

#Underground!
 

glyders

Member
mch said:
I wonder if they bothered to ask BMC members their view on the proposed change of name - sorry, "rebranding"?
They certainly did not!

I too initially reacted that it was due to the Olympic hopes for indoor climbing and bouldering. I have seen the same happen to canoeing and cycling, with some quite bad effects on those who jut want to take up the activity but have no intention to become 'athletes'.
 

Duncan S

New member
andrewmcleod said:
Over the Hill said:
BMC lost its way some time ago and still the best value all around for International "CLIMB" trips is to join the OEAV or as known in UK as the Austrian Alpine Club. Cheaper and some good insurance thrown in (personal choice to check if it covers all you want it too as it has limits but caving is included) . Also gets me discounts staying in huts where a BMC card does not.

Be careful with the limits on AAC insurance though - you may just about be OK in Europe but the cover is definitely not enough for some places. BMC insurance is provided by a (recently changed) broker and is expensive but comprehensive with much higher limits.
I just tried BMC insurance and was told caving is not covered.
They didn't even get as far as asking what country of what kind of caving.
 

mikem

Well-known member
Hmm, it used to (except expedition stuff), but now only "Black Water Rafting (professionally organised)" on their Alpine & Ski cover...

Mike
 
Top