Pitlamp said:
The Old Ruminator wrote: "Personally I am not sure how a reluctance to publish new bits of cave here can be justified."
I've been mulling this comment over for a while and have a lot of empathy with this sentiment. But I thought at least some readers might appreciate my own take on the thought.
I too have thought a lot about this. While I agree with both of you, another truth does exist. In most cases there is no obligation to report on any trip or discovery. Sometimes acceptance of a grant or permit creates a commitment to report, otherwise it's the decision of the caver(s) doing the work. Some do not like to write and feel no need to gloat over their discoveries. Others are competitive and secretive. Others wait for a neverending project to be finished. Whatever the case, we can't really complain about a lack of reporting. They don't owe us anything. I say this despite my strong belief in the value of thorough and accessible (not necessarily easily) documentation.
If I may add some personal boasting, my own exploration has been both successful and interesting lately. When I was an NSS member and the NSS forum was active, I used to write straightforward and detailed trip reports for club publications or the NSS News, and semi-poetic narratives for the forum. I have continued to write in both styles, but having no suitable means to publish incrementally am organizing this material into a second book. I feel sure it will be unique, including original data, maps, trip reports, sketches, statistics, essays, interviews, poetry, historical and geographical profiles, and photographs within a single volume. Whether or not it will be good is a bigger question.