• Descent 298 publication date

    Our June/July issue will be published on Saturday 8 June

    Now with four extra pages as standard. If you want to receive it as part of your subscription, make sure you sign up or renew by Monday 27 May.

    Click here for more

Heightec Prism descender

cap n chris

Well-known member
FWIW I don't use maillons for sports caving rigging (generally - except at work where there's getting on for about three hundred of them, for which an adjustable spanner is the preferred tool's tool, obviously) so the multifunctional usefulness of the old style Stop for spannering a variety of maillons (thus negating the need to carry 2-3 different spanner sizes, if you actually needed to have one with you) meant it was a neat and nice design characteristic but seldom needed - nice when it was needed, though, eh. My guess is that people who routinely rig using maillons would indeed have a spanner for doing that (not on elastic, remember!, but tied to you somehow or another) although using them is tedious and the comparative cost nowadays with compact alloy carabiners means it's an easy decision to use the latter for sports caving trips. The Stop also spanners your central maillon if you're using an old style one rather than one of those new-fangled Omnis with their Triact or Screw Gate superfast operational feature(s).
 

mikem

Well-known member
Because, provided that you know what you are doing, it may be better for you than the alternatives...
 

Loki

Active member
It's safe worn, rather than unsafe worn, just well used. It's the piece of kit I'll replace next though I think.
It’s not worn, it’s experienced 🙂. If the threads of the bolt aren’t visible it ain’t done yet 😜 kidding
 

cap n chris

Well-known member
Find me a half decent caver with equipment in tip top condition!
Ian Patrick (and a host of others I know of/well) keep their gear in immaculate condition; it reminds me (although I don't have his book to hand so will have to paraphrase from memory) of Dave Elliot's dry quip that "any caver who can't be bothered to look after their gear should give up".
 

AlexR

Active member
I'd say "tip top condition" is a slightly polemic choice of words, a single caving trip can give your brand spanking new gear an appearance that would make any non-caving wise H&S monkey employee blanch at the idea of continued use - but I would deem perfectly safe (metalware), though other bits may not be (soft goods).
Ultimately any cavers life entirely depends on their SRT kit, if that's not motivation enough to keep it in good shape I don't know what is.

@cap n chris :
Looks like we're on the same page when it comes to the Stop though, I'm simply delaying the inevitable by using a specially manufactures stainless top bobbin and getting my mitts on a couple of the remaining bottom (handle) bobbins. Only managed to wear a single aluminium side plate in 10 years, so probably fine on that front. Then for digging/ trade routes I use a BMS rack which sees most of the wear*, but find an old style Stop way superior for rigging.

*and I would thoroughly recommend to anyone putting in a decent mileage on ropes, about 3km for the top bobbin which you can then flip to get 6km. For reference the top bobbin of my Stop needs replacing every 1.5km or so, the bottom bobbin about 4km. This is predominantly Derbyshire digging on in situ ropes, Yorkshire will provide better numbers.
 

cap n chris

Well-known member
IMG_20230707_121725.jpg
 

Loki

Active member
I think most cavers are pretty sensible and know when their gear is fecked tbh. The only incidents I know of that fortunately didn’t involve injuries were due to trusting in situ ropes and rigging or worn out spits. Most people can use their own intelligence and make thier own assessments and decisions on their personal safety.
 

Cantclimbtom

Well-known member
I think most cavers are pretty sensible and know when their gear is fecked tbh. The only incidents I know of that fortunately didn’t involve injuries were due to trusting in situ ropes and rigging or worn out spits. Most people can use their own intelligence and make thier own assessments and decisions on their personal safety.
Think I mentioned on here before, that the first ever drop of my first ever access job (many many moons ago, in a "past life") the Stop I was issued by large/famous access company looked OK (note "looked" OK not "inspected" OK) self destructed when I sat on the rope. Thank *** for a shunt rope and the footloop I was standing in. It looked fine but salt water corrosion from previous jobs had done something bad to the nut that held the lower handle/bobbin and also the hinge, both of which just fell off. The L3 was next to me at the top watching me as he knew it was my first job and he quickly confiscated the broken stop swapping for his one (hide the evidence) and forbade me to discuss it. He packed me off down the rope before I could change my mind. So I am in agreement that inspection of kit is essential as life depends on it, the anecdote given changed my attitude from a casual attitude to thorough inspection and replacement when needed.

But I also agree with you.... there's a balance between inspecting kit for safety and some extreme idolising, polishing, sleeping with it, keeping in a display case attitude (a gross exaggeration... not saying any posters here are that extreme). Dunno very much about caves, but certainly in mines and other foolish outdoor uses I put srt kit and ropes to, it can get a beating. It's working kit after all so it needs to work for a living!
 

Edz

New member
The key difference is that caving kit is usually your own so you know it's history etc. The exception is club kit but it's still being used by people who generally want to keep it in reasonable condition.
Work kit suffers from the 'someone else's problem/can't be bothered' syndrome. Handing damaged stuff back in and hoping no one will notice or a thorough examination that's not very thorough.
 

cap n chris

Well-known member
I think most cavers are pretty sensible and know when their gear is fecked tbh. The only incidents I know of that fortunately didn’t involve injuries were due to trusting in situ ropes and rigging or worn out spits. Most people can use their own intelligence and make thier own assessments and decisions on their personal safety.
Sadly plenty of examples disprove this in my experience.
 
Top