• BCA Finances

    An informative discussion

    Recently there was long thread about the BCA. I can now post possible answers to some of the questions, such as "Why is the BCA still raising membership prices when there is a significant amount still left in its coffers?"

    Click here for more

Charging people to enter the Peak District?

mikem

Well-known member
This sort of suggestion is usually just a cover for them sneaking something else through, as they know the public won't go for it...
 

RobinGriffiths

Well-known member
Fulk said:
...and the extra income tax distributed to local councils in lieu of the CT.

Ah yes, but it'll get allocated politically then depending on whether you voted in the government or are seen to be a potential swing voter.
 

mrodoc

Well-known member
Down our way some coastal towns have introduced Park and Ride and this should be the first move before congestion charges. Strategically developed it would solve a lot of problems.  At some sites round here P&D is free to use as well. That would (theoretically) cut out all those not carrying heavy gear although that is probably wishful thinking! 
 

cavemanmike

Well-known member
mrodoc said:
Down our way some coastal towns have introduced Park and Ride and this should be the first move before congestion charges. Strategically developed it would solve a lot of problems.  At some sites round here P&D is free to use as well. That would (theoretically) cut out all those not carrying heavy gear although that is probably wishful thinking!
Lik I said  (y)
 

Fatman

Member
On a different but related aspect are the camper vans parked up below Mam Tor, on the top road NR Stanage edge, etc.. I saw one with a lit BBQ next to a fire warning sign, I did say something to him. They do little to support local business and can cause parking and health issues. Down Glencoe etc there is no overnight parking allowed perhaps it's time to clamp down on this in the Peak. :chair:
 

alastairgott

Well-known member
pwhole said:
. One hilarious and expensive option would be to reopen the Buxton to Derby line, calling at Monsal Dale, Millers Dale, etc. But given the trackbed is the only path most visitors would choose to walk, all other options involving slopes, and given it's also a popular cycling and disabled route, good luck with that.

I know of at least one local that uses that line to commute from tides' to bakewell. So ironically a measure to improve the "congestion/eco friendlyness" of the peak would see a cyclist either adding carbons getting on a train or would get in their car instead.
 

Cantclimbtom

Well-known member
cavemanmike said:
How about a park and ride for visitors
Thinking about this for all touristy areas not peak specific, and I'm sure if one area did it others would follow:

While park and ride is great as one of the options they should have, some people like me struggle with them as I want to arrive, leave or both at times that aren't 9-5
Also would the congestion charge be ploughed back into public transport or would the council just see it as a nice little earner?

Interesting to see a green candidate who works (and lives?) in Essex representing constituents/parishioners in the Peak, doesn't sound like she can represent them well, or has a lot of commuting which doesn't fit with a climate change emergency stance. Never understood why politicians at all levels don't have to have their (genuine) primary residence within some distance of their constituents, but that's another thread!
 

mikem

Well-known member
She left Essex 10 years ago & was a nurse in Sheffield before becoming a lawyer, so presumably not wealthy by southern standards (also only a parish councillor not member of parliament, she is a member of the green party but not representing them): http://bamfordwiththornhill-pc.gov.uk/councillors/cn-farrell
 

Ed

Active member
mikem said:
She left Essex 10 years ago & was a nurse in Sheffield before becoming a lawyer, so presumably not wealthy by southern standards (also only a parish councillor not member of parliament, she is a member of the green party but not representing them): http://bamfordwiththornhill-pc.gov.uk/councillors/cn-farrell

Usual situation - there would be no parish council or only a few old land owning parish councillors if it wasn't for folks that move into the area and intend to stay long term.

Same goes for most community initiatives
 

pwhole

Well-known member
Winnats Pass was closed today due to the weather, and Castleton was deserted - virtually no traffic at all through the village. Which kind of reinforces the point I made - take Winnats out of the equation and not many non-locals are interested in driving to (or through) Castleton.
 

dbrock

New member
It can be difficult to get to the caves of Derbyshire without a car but, Pierre Chevalier managed an even more arduous journey in the 1940's when exploring the Trou du Glaz.  On Saturday morning, Pierre would arrive from Lyon by train, and having brought his bike, would pedal a dozen kilometers from the train station in Grenoble to Saint-Ismier. From there, wearing old mountaineering clothes, the whole group would ride their bikes up a steep hill (12km long and 800m ascent) to the sanatorium in Saint Hilaire du Touvet. A three-hour hike was then required to reach the entrance of the Trou du Glaz cave at 1,700 meters elevation. During the first few years, their backpacks were weighed down by rolled ladders with wooden rungs and battery packs for their electric lamps.  They would usually emerge sometime late Sunday evening, if not Monday morning at dawn? Upon their return, staggering with fatigue after having gone without sleep for dozens of hours, they would hop on their bicycles, which were ingeniously outfitted to keep the brakes from wearing out too quickly: a bundle of sticks anchored to the back of the bicycle or a rod dragging on the ground beneath the pedals, served as brakes. A hazardous affair indeed, but nothing compared to two days spent exploring the bowels of the earth.
 

Mrs Trellis

Well-known member
Bikes? Trains? Luxury! We 'ad to set off 'alf an 'our before we went to bed to walk to Giant's, eat a bowl o' cold grit, and when we got 'ome our mums and dads would cut us in 'alf wi't' breadknife.... and you tell young cavers today an' they won't believe you Eli.
 

pwhole

Well-known member
Jim Rieuwerts once told me he sometimes walked back to Sheffield from Castleton in the early 50s after missing the last bus. I assume he wasn't working the next day when this happened.
 

topcat

Active member
Fatman said:
On a different but related aspect are the camper vans parked up below Mam Tor, on the top road NR Stanage edge, etc.. I saw one with a lit BBQ next to a fire warning sign, I did say something to him. They do little to support local business and can cause parking and health issues. Down Glencoe etc there is no overnight parking allowed perhaps it's time to clamp down on this in the Peak. :chair:

The no overnight parking in Glencoe  was challenged and deemed to be an illegal action by the Council.  Signs were removed some years ago.
 

A_Northerner

Active member
pwhole said:
Jim Rieuwerts once told me he sometimes walked back to Sheffield from Castleton in the early 50s after missing the last bus. I assume he wasn't working the next day when this happened.

SUSS members have been known to walk to Castleton, do a ropey SRT trip (Oxlow-Maskhill exchange, Titan-JH etc) and then walk back home as endurance training before an exped.
 

Fulk

Well-known member
A hazardous affair indeed, but nothing compared to two days spent exploring the bowels of the earth.

Hmmm, I'm not convinced of that . . . I wonder if the underground bit would have been the easier paart!!
 

kay

Well-known member
mikem said:
Roads weren't so busy in those days
One of the traffic report pages on Facebook frequently has warnings to beware of a pedestrian on A65, the general tone reminding me of telling people to beware of a pushbike on the M1. Good to be aware of pedestrians, especially in dark clothing at night, but not good if people are beginning to think that people are not allowed to walk along busy roads.
 

al

Member
kay said:
mikem said:
Roads weren't so busy in those days
One of the traffic report pages on Facebook frequently has warnings to beware of a pedestrian on A65, the general tone reminding me of telling people to beware of a pushbike on the M1. Good to be aware of pedestrians, especially in dark clothing at night, but not good if people are beginning to think that people are not allowed to walk along busy roads.

When I was keyholding for Peak Cavern, I regularly cycled across from Hayfield to let cavers in to the cavern. The scariest road by far was the A624 between Hayfield and Chapel. You expect the smaller lanes (like Winnats) to be the worst, but the speed of vehicles on the A roads is much higher, and if two cars going in opposite directions (or worse still, lorries) meet at a point where there is a cyclist, a very close pass is inevitable. And it doesn't matter how bright your clothing is.

That route's going to be much busier over the next few weeks now that the Snake's being closed because of the landslides.

 
Top