• CSCC Newsletter - May 2024

    Available now. Includes details of upcoming CSCC Annual General Meeting 10th May 2024

    Click here for more info

Giant's Hole Payment Box Vandalism

seddon

New member
Good idea.

What's the preference for what type of wood the stakes should be made out of? Something solid and long lasting gets my vote...
 

ronaldjprice

New member
As it is the Farmer/landowner is attracting thieves & vandals, not the types you would want in your garden I remember my local farmer removing these types with a shotgun.
Perhaps a payment system whereby we paid in a local  shop/pub/cave and gaind a pay & display ticket.
Ron
 

Jenny P

Active member
The new payment box at Giants, the postbox cemented into the wall, may last a little longer this time we hope.

Best if you pay by cheque, payable to Peakshill Farm.  Then if the b*****s vandalise the box they will not be able to get hold of any useable cash.

Stake-out sounds a nice idea though.
 

SeeJay

Member
Jenny P said:
The new payment box at Giants, the postbox cemented into the wall, may last a little longer this time we hope.

Sadly not, we were there last night and someone has smashed the front off it.

Thieving barstewards.

Maybe Ron's suggestion above is worth considering?
 

SamT

Moderator
I still stand by my original post on the subject, If we are going to keep putting money in a box in the middle of nowhere, it will continue to get broken into / nicked. No matter how strong it is. They'll always have a go.

I know when there where repeated car break ins at Stanage Plantation car park, and at Curbar Gap car park, the authories set up a little sting operation with hidden cameras.

As the breakins where almost daily, it didnt take long to capture the culprits in film.

Problem here is that its every 2 or 3 months, so it could be a while.

Still - Im sure its not beyond some of the technical boffins on here to come up with a little camera that could be buried in one of the walls near by pointing at the moneybox. Linked to a sensor in the box, (motion sensor. microswitch or somesort). door comes off, camera turns on. bingo.


 

Cave_Troll

Active member
a better option would be a solid state recorder, that when the switch is triggered, saves the last 5mins and the next 5 mins.
If you just record when its tripped, you'll miss their faces and reg number while their hooking the chains up to the car.
 

SamT

Moderator
Cave_Troll said:
a better option would be a solid state recorder, that when the switch is triggered, saves the last 5mins and the next 5 mins.
If you just record when its tripped, you'll miss their faces and reg number while their hooking the chains up to the car.

see - told you there were boffins on this site.
 

ronaldjprice

New member
Has anyone heard the views or ideas of the land owner?
It would be a great loss to the caving community to lose access to Giants Hole and surely that must worry us if no satisfactory alternative is found.
Perhaps on line prepayment via Paypal or bank transfer could be another option.
Leaving bait out for the thieves will only attract others, although it might be a sporting prospect!
Ron
 

paul

Moderator
As I already said: cheques.

If you leave any high-tech gear to record incidents (who's going to pay for this anyway?) that will get nicked as well. Paying online, etc means the owner has no idea if anyone parked there has paid or not.

Once the thieves have broken in a few times more and got nothing for their troubles but a load of useless cheques (pay by cheque, ?3.00 per person, making cheques payable to Peakshill Farm) they'l soon give up.


 

Elaine

Active member
The problem with cheques is that they are then a traceable (and therefore accountable for) source of income, and the farmer is not going to like that unless he currently declares every payment he gets in goodwill fees to the Inland Revenue.

Another thing to remember is bank charge a fee for paying cheques in.

 

Stu

Active member
I wouldn't have thought losing access to the cave is that likely; I'd guess it's not a bad pocket money earner for the owner. In the old days we used to pay at the farm (and get changed in the barn) - is this not viable anymore (the paying not the changing)?
 

bubba

Administrator
paul said:
Paying online, etc means the owner has no idea if anyone parked there has paid or not.
Even if cheques are used the farmer will be none the wiser as to who has paid and who hasn't unless he/she is constantly watching the car park. Does the farmer enforce payment anyway? It's more of an honest box isn't it?
 

paul

Moderator
Elaine said:
The problem with cheques is that they are then a traceable (and therefore accountable for) source of income, and the farmer is not going to like that unless he currently declares every payment he gets in goodwill fees to the Inland Revenue.

Another thing to remember is bank charge a fee for paying cheques in.

It's probably better to loose a bit of the income to the taxman than to regularly loose all of it....

I've paid in many, many cheques since having a bank accout for at least 25 years, both into personal bank accounts and also for other organisations' bank accounts (I'm a Treasurer, for my sins). I have NEVER paid a single penny to pay in a cheque!

Anyway, the official position as stated on the DCA website is : pay by cheque.

 
Top