Old carabiner

Thought people might be interested.  The gate failed so I have used it on my plastic washing line in the garden for a few (I think 3) years. 

 

Attachments

  • Shrunk 1.jpg
    Shrunk 1.jpg
    120.3 KB · Views: 1,888
  • Shrunk 2.jpg
    Shrunk 2.jpg
    106.4 KB · Views: 180
  • Shrunk 3.jpg
    Shrunk 3.jpg
    137.8 KB · Views: 175
  • Shrunk 4.jpg
    Shrunk 4.jpg
    133.2 KB · Views: 187

Fulk

Well-known member
Your point being? That it's got f***** up by being left out in the open for a few years? Not being sarcastic (honestly), just inquisitive.
 

ttxela2

Active member
Surprising if that's just 3 years, I'm thinking of various bits of aluminium on my car and van that are regularly exposed to wet conditions, road salt etc and are 20-30 years old  :confused:
 

zzzzzzed

Member
Those look like Clog crabs.  Didn't they go bust in 1986?  That makes them 35 years old at a minimum.
 

mikem

Well-known member
Wild Country bought the brand (don't think original Clog had coloured gates):
https://www.ukclimbing.com/forums/gear/clog_equipment-633427
 
Fulk said:
Your point being? That it's got f***** up by being left out in the open for a few years? Not being sarcastic (honestly), just inquisitive.

I have just found it interesting as to how it splits when it degrades.  I have not had the chance to see that before, hence the post, to show others.

It could be very old, I used it as a hook on a plastic line to hang the peg bag, also plastic.  It was left out though, all the time.
 

Fulk

Well-known member
Thanks Judi; I realize that when people say ?Your point being?, they?re generally being sarcastic or offensive or patronizing, so I?m sorry I phrased my remark rather badly.
 

andrewmcleod

Well-known member
ttxela2 said:
Surprising if that's just 3 years, I'm thinking of various bits of aluminium on my car and van that are regularly exposed to wet conditions, road salt etc and are 20-30 years old  :confused:

The alloys of aluminium used in carabiners are less corrosion-resistant than most aluminium alloys, due primarily to copper.
https://dmmclimbing.com/Knowledge/August-2011/Anodising
 

phizz4

Member
Interesting. I've got a Clog krab that I use for exactly the same purpose, and it's even older than yours. One end is through some braided cord, the other has a plastic clip going into it. It's been in use (hanging on a concrete fence post) for over 3 years and isn't corroded at all. The gate still opoens and closes.
 

mikem

Well-known member
It also depends where it was used (& how it was cared for) beforehand - some areas have high iron content, which will promote corrosion.
 

tomferry

Well-known member
It?s mad how the layers of the materials have separated like that watch out you don?t get them nasty splinters in your feet under where it was !
 

SamT

Moderator
I've jugged up a rope before to find it attached to a very similarly corroded krab,  and later, the spit it was attached to pulled straight out of the hole.  :eek:

Reckon that was one of the 9 used up there.

Infact - I've found my photo of it.

Usually happens when ali krabs are in contact with steel hangers.
 

Attachments

  • 2381007058_78aefbbdb7_o.jpg
    2381007058_78aefbbdb7_o.jpg
    9.5 KB · Views: 644

Pitlamp

Well-known member
Here's one that was steeped in "phreatic acid" for 19 years. It was joining two lines together a long way into Keld Head in the Dales. I kept swimming past and trying to ignore it but in the end cut it out and repaired the line.

Thought it might just be worth pointing out here, to fellow sump floppers, that the use of metal connectors to join lines in underwater caves is maybe not as great an idea as we all once thought. Lines are best joined directly, by looping, as per standard practice nowadays.
 

Attachments

  • P6180547.JPG
    P6180547.JPG
    3.8 MB · Views: 157
As a fellow "sump flopper"  ;) , I would add that the problem is not confined to karabiners. I once came across a half-full line reel which had been left in a sump for many years. Being made of a combination of steel studding and aluminium plates, it had suffered the inevitable corrosion and, when touched, fell to bits and discharged loads of looped line. Mercifully, the visibility was good and it was easily sorted.
 

Mark Wright

Well-known member
Badlad and I were talking about this earlier.

About 30 years ago, he and I climbed a 90m high council incinerator chimney near Nottingham. Our job was to climb it and get it rigged so that in a couple or three weeks time, when the incinerator would be turned off, we could carry out a full internal examination of the stack by rope access.

The incinerator was running when we did the climb, over a couple of days if I remember. The view from 10m from the top was spectacular. We were surprised to see a 10m missile propped up against a wall in some ex-military equipment supplier near the bottom of the chimney. It turned out to be one of the famous Anchor Supplies depots.

We didn't buy the missile as it wouldn't fit on top of our van but Badlad did buy 8000 AG3B flash bulbs. He's probably still got a few left.

Back to the climb. Ropes were attached with Faders Offset D alloy carabiners. These were standard issue for personal rope access kits at the company we worked for.  These were subsequently attached to steel Petzl hangers that we had installed to do the climb. We had chosen alloy carabiners for the climb as they were much lighter than the steel carabiners the company usually issued for rigging purposes.   

The next time we went to the top, no more than 3 weeks later, the Faders carabiners were very badly corroded. Not quite as bad as in the example photos, but enough to always remember not to leave dissimilar metals connected to each other for long periods, particularly at the top of an operational incinerator stack.

I've got a couple of Clog carabiners that are well over 40 years old that still look and operate like new. They would certainly pass a Thorough Examination.

Mark
 

zzzzzzed

Member
There's an interesting video made by DMM about anodising crabs here...
https://vimeo.com/28055128

Anodising prevents galvanic corrosion in aluminium crabs.  If you look at the original photo you can see that the gate on the crab is coloured because it has been anodised and hasn?t corroded to the same extent.

They show some similar examples in the video.
 

Fjell

Well-known member
Bare-hulled aluminium boats happily float for decades in saltwater with no issue. It?s when you introduce current from some source you get the problems. Bare aluminium is used for most of the serious boats you can buy for heading out into the sticks. It?s the cheese.
 

droid

Active member
If you want corrosion you should have seen some of the pegs me and a mate ended up clipping on Gogarth  :LOL:
 
Top